A healthcare reform that Democrats and Republicans can agree on

Image by atlascompany on Magnific

By Howard Dean and Larry Bucshon

We’ve spent our entire political careers in different camps. One of us was a Democratic governor and chairman of the DNC. The other served as a conservative Republican in Congress for over a decade, representing a deep-red district that President Trump repeatedly won by over 30 points.

But before we got into politics, we were both physicians. We’ve seen how crucial it is for the patient-provider relationship to determine the right care. And that’s why we’re so alarmed that nearly half of Americans now report their health insurers have delayed or denied coverage for a doctor-recommended treatment within the past two years.

Corporate insurers should not be at the forefront of patient care. Delays and denials put patients’ health at risk. And they often lead to preventable complications and higher long-term spending.

We both believe reforming the health insurance system is a moral, and an economic, imperative as do our colleagues on both sides of the aisle.

In recent months, Democrats and Republicans have worked together to hold insurers accountable — especially when it comes to “prior authorization,” the insurer practice of denying certain procedures and treatments unless doctors and patients first obtain permission.

In a recent American Medical Association survey, 95% of physicians said they’ve seen prior authorization requirements delay necessary care. Nearly four in five have seen patients abandon treatment because of problems with the process.

Leaders in both parties already agree that improvements to the American insurance model are necessary. The bipartisan Improving Seniors’ Timely Access to Care Act would move Medicare Advantage prior authorizations to an electronic system and require quicker response times and greater transparency from insurers. Over 300 House members and 70 senators have cosponsored the legislation. This summer, it cleared two House committees unanimously.

Lawmakers are also finding common ground on transparency. This July, the House Energy and Commerce Committee advanced a bipartisan bill that would require health insurers to publicly report how often they deny claims.

That scrutiny is overdue. Medicare Advantage insurers denied more than 4 million prior authorization requests in 2024.

When patients and their doctors appealed those denials, insurers reversed roughly 80% of their initial decisions. That high reversal rate suggests insurers are denying lots of medically appropriate procedures, tests, and treatments — and hoping that doctors and patients will be too busy, sick, and frustrated to follow through with an appeal.

That’s often a safe, albeit callous, bet. For too many Americans, fighting insurers can feel like a battle they cannot win. That is why Congress must take on that fight for them.

As a Democrat and a Republican, we recognize how rare genuine consensus is in Washington. That’s why we’re cautiously hopeful that Congress will seize the opportunity to make prior authorization and broader insurance marketplace reforms a priority.

Howard Dean, MD, is the former chair of the Democratic National Committee and former governor of Vermont. Larry Bucshon, MD, a cardiothoracic surgeon, served as the U.S. representative for Indiana’s 8th congressional district from 2011 to 2025. This piece originally ran in Salon.

- Advertisement -
- Advertisement -
- Advertisement -
- Advertisement -

Related Articles