The New Coney Island Casino Between Controversy and Development

Photo from Unsplash.com

A proposed new casino in Coney Island is facing setback after setback due to the local community opposing the development. However, recently, the casino resort is one step closer to being constructed due to approval by the New York City Planning Commission.

Gambling is becoming a popular pastime throughout the United States, both online and in person. Although many states still have restrictive gambling laws, workarounds like sweepstakes casinos and card rooms have allowed citizens to enjoy casino games across the nation. This popularity is also in part due to clever marketing campaigns employed by casino operators, like using an affiliate marketing network to get their offerings seen by a wider audience (source: https://ghostpartners.com/). 

Despite this embrace of gambling by lawmakers across the country, New Yorkers were strongly opposed to the Coney Island development. However, the New York City Planning Commission has now approved a plan for the development, which will include the casino, as well as a hotel, retail area, and convention center. This approval comes as a surprise since the Land Use Committee rejected an application for a new road that would serve the casino complex. 

The main debates against the development center around increased traffic, crime, and the negative impact on small local businesses. However, there is also some support from residents who see the entertainment complex as a potential for job creation and new investment in the area. 

The development application will next move on to the New York City Council, where there will be a public hearing and vote. Even if the Council approves the development, it will still have to secure a casino license. The New York State Gaming Facility Location Board will only extend three casino licenses for the downstate area. 

The license application deadline is June 27, 2025, and the developers must satisfy all requirements from the Community Advisory Committee by September 30, 2025. The current estimated date for license decisions is December 1, 2025. 

If all goes to plan, according to the developers, the casino will likely only be operational by 2026 earliest. 

The topic of downstate casinos has long been contested. New Yorkers voted in 2013 that casinos be allowed, with three downstate and four upstate casinos planned. However, a 10-year moratorium on downstate casinos was enforced to allow the upstate establishments to operate first. Now that the 10 years are coming to an end, there is plenty of interest in the three downstate licenses. 

Other notable operators wanting to get a license include Caesars, Wynn Resorts, and MGM Resorts. Caesars and Roc Nation is working towards the approval for Times Square; a $1 billion investment which will include a casino, hotel, restaurants, and entertainment venues. 

The Coney Island project and other proposals will likely result in a big shift in New York’s gambling scene. The city may soon become a premier destination for gamblers, boosting the local economy, tourism, and creating many jobs.