When a person faces a criminal charge, the first task is to find the right legal help. Yet the way that help is found can look quite different in the UK and the US. The terms may also sound the same, but the roles are not the same.
In the UK, a criminal law barrister may act as the main court voice in a case, often after being hired by a solicitor. However, in the US, a criminal defence lawyer will often deal with the case from its first stage to its end. Knowing this gap can help you ask the right things when you need legal help. So in this article, we will discuss in detail how hiring a criminal law barrister in the UK differs from hiring a criminal defence attorney in the US.
Photo from Magnific.com
Division of Labour and Hiring Process
The UK has a split legal role that may seem odd to a US client. Here, a solicitor will often deal with the daily work. They may take your first call, help in case of an emergency, deal with the police, sort key documents, and work with the CPS. For a case that needs a court voice, the solicitor may then brief a barrister. The barrister is a court and case law professional. The Bar Council says barristers are courtroom representatives. This can mean the client does not pick a barrister in the same way a US client picks a defence lawyer.
There is now also a Direct Access route in the UK. Some barristers can be hired by the public with no need to first use a solicitor. But this route has its own limits. For one, barristers on Direct Access cannot do legal work under that scheme.
In the US, the set-up is less split in this way. A criminal defence lawyer can deal with case preparation, court work, and trial work as part of one legal role. If a person cannot pay for a lawyer in a US federal case, the court can appoint a lawyer under the Criminal Justice Act system.
Independence and Work Structure
The work set-up also has clear gaps between the UK and the US. Many UK barristers may work in a set of chambers with other barristers, but each barrister is an independent legal professional. The Bar Council notes that this model is still common, though some barristers work in law firms or in-house. That can shape how a client deals with the legal team. Your solicitor may deal with you each day, while your barrister may step in for key advice or court dates.
Court Appearance Rights
This is one of the key gaps. A UK barrister is trained to represent clients in court. Their work can focus on bail, trial, appeal, and other court work. A UK solicitor may also get higher rights of audience. Moreover, the SRA has a route for solicitors to gain rights to act as an advocate in criminal and civil cases. So, do not assume that each UK case must have both a solicitor and barrister in court. The need will depend on the case, court, and role of the legal professional.
The US uses a bar system. A lawyer must have the right to act in the court where the case is. Furthermore, for a US federal court, a lawyer may need a court bar pass or a form of local admission. Some courts also have rules for an out-of-state lawyer who seeks to act in one case. This means a US lawyer may not act in each court in the land. The right to act can be connected to the bar and court in which the case is set.
Seeking Legal Help in the UK or US?
The UK and US both give a person the right to seek legal help when facing a crime case, but the way that help is set up can be quite different. In the UK, the split role of solicitor and barrister can mean that two legal professionals share the work. In the US, one defence lawyer may take a case from start to end, though the exact set-up can vary by court and state.
Legal Disclaimer:
Please be advised that this article is for informational purposes only and should not be used as a substitute for advice from a trained legal professional. UK and US criminal law, court rules, rights of audience, and lawyer roles can vary by case and place. Please seek the advice of a qualified legal professional if you are facing a criminal charge or need help with a criminal law matter in the UK or US.