An Opinion Piece by Legislators Jewel Williams Johnson and Shanae Williams
As elected representatives of Westchester County, we are compelled to address the recent remarks made by Congressman Mike Lawler during a public meeting with the Westchester County Board of Legislators. His statement to our colleague, Vice Chair José Alvarado—”I assume you’re a citizen; maybe you’re not”—was both deeply offensive and emblematic of a broader insensitivity. This attitude undermines the dignity of all in the 17th Congressional District.
Many Americans who have never had to question their place in the United States of America struggle to understand why ICE’s presence in communities of color is problematic. To them, it’s easy to say, “Just cooperate with ICE” or “Just show your documents,” and life will go on. For many people of color, however, ICE represents more than just an immigration enforcement agency; it is a symbol of racialized oppression and state-sanctioned violence.
It sparks fear woven into communities of color—not only for Latinos and undocumented residents, but also for naturalized citizens, asylum seekers, mixed-race families, Indigenous people, and those of the African diaspora, all of whom live under systemic threats rooted in hatred.
We, at the Westchester County Board of Legislators, held a public meeting with the Westchester Federal Delegation to discuss the County’s 2025 agenda and address pressing issues.
During our wide-ranging conversation the Vice Chair of the Board, José Alvarado, asked Rep. Lawler, what he, as a Latino and sitting member of the Board of Legislators, should do if ICE were to approach him. This was an opportunity for the Republican representative to show some compassion and ease the fear so many people of color and immigrants experience daily. Instead, Mr. Lawler chose to deflect and disrespect Vice Chair Alvarado by insinuating he may be undocumented. He actually asked if he was a citizen.
If anyone should know that elected officials in New York State must be citizens to run for office, it would be Rep. Lawler, himself an elected official in New York.
Vice Chair Alvarado, a naturalized U.S. citizen born in Honduras, has dedicated his career to public service, representing the diverse community of Yonkers with integrity and commitment. Questioning his citizenship status, especially in a public forum, is a blatant display of disrespect and ignorance. Such remarks demean an esteemed public servant and send a chilling message to immigrants and naturalized citizens about their place in society.
As an immigrant from Jamaica, I, Legislator Shanae Williams, understand first-hand the challenges and triumphs that come with building a life in the United States. My journey, like that of many others, is a testament to resilience and the pursuit of the American dream.
Similarly, I, Legislator Jewel Williams Johnson, often reflect on my family’s history; my maternal grandfather immigrated to the U.S., from the dual island nation, the Federation of St. Kitts and Nevis, in the 1930s with barely any belongings, wrapping newspapers around his feet for shoes. His perseverance laid the foundation for our family’s future.
These personal narratives are not unique; they echo the experiences of countless families who have contributed to the rich tapestry of our nation.
It is mortifying that a Congressional representative would question the legitimacy of a fellow elected official in such a manner. Congressman Lawler was an invited guest at a Committee of the Whole meeting, convened to discuss our concerns regarding recent sweeping changes to federal policies, funding, staffing, and programs. Instead of providing assurances, he issued threats, incorrectly labeled Westchester as a “sanctuary county,” and insulted our colleague.
This behavior exacerbates an already fraught environment, fostering division rather than unity. As legislators, our duty is to ensure the well-being and quality of life for all our constituents, irrespective of their background. We expect the same commitment from our federal representatives.
A public and sincere apology from Congressman Lawler is not only warranted but necessary. Respect for one’s colleagues and constituents is fundamental to effective governance. According to the US Census Bureau and Data USA, the racial and ethnic composition of Congressional District 17 includes approximately 20% who identify as Hispanic or Latino, approximately 8% who identify as Black or African American and approximately 5% who identify as Asian. Notably, 31.8% of households in the district report speaking a non-English language at home, reflecting the linguistic diversity of the area. We urge Congressman Lawler to reflect on his actions and to engage with all communities in his district and beyond with the respect and dignity they deserve.
In these challenging times, it is imperative that our leaders exemplify the values of inclusivity, respect, and understanding. Only then can we truly serve the diverse and vibrant communities that make up our great county and nation.
About the Authors:
Jewel Williams Johnson was elected to the Westchester County Legislature in November 2021 to represent the constituents of the 8th Legislative District. Jewel serves as Chair of both the Board of Legislators ’Committee on Budget & Appropriations and the Committee on Health.
Shanae Williams was elected to the Westchester County Legislature in November 2023 to represent the 16th Legislative District. Shanae serves as Chair of the Housing and Planning Committee.
